Cardi B, Jennifer Lopez and more best-dressed stars on the 2018 American Music Awards red carpet

Tyra Banks. Macaulay Culkin. Amber Heard. John Stamos. Cobie Smulders. Taran Killam. Kyle Richards. These are just a few of the stars on hand at the red carpet for the 2018 American Music Awards. There were, of course, musicians on hand, but this year’s carpet made space for an overwhelming amount of nonsingers.

Oh sure, at the awards show, we got our first red carpet appearance by Taylor Swift since the Billboard Music Awards in May, the debut of Mariah Carey’s new single “With You” and a powerful Aretha Franklin tribute anchored by Gladys Knight and featuring Ledisi, Mary Mary, Donnie McClurkin and CeCe Winans. But the show, and by proxy the fashions, felt strangely redundant.

This could perhaps be award show fatigue, having come off a lackluster MTV Video Music Awards in August, but something about Tuesday night’s show felt notably unenthused. Swift wore Balmain. Cardi wore Dolce & Gabbana. J. Lo wore a plunging neckline Georges Chakra. We’ve seen this all before.

Everyone looked good, but did anyone look great? You decide.

Taylor Swift

Taylor SwiftSteve Granitz/Getty Images

Chloe x Halle

Halle Bailey and Chloe Bailey of Chloe x HalleFrazer Harrison/Getty Images

Carrie Underwood

Carrie UnderwoodEmma McIntyre/Getty Images

Jennifer Lopez

Jennifer LopezFrazer Harrison/Getty Images

Cardi B

Cardi BEmma McIntyre/Getty Images

Rita Ora

Rita OraFrazer Harrison/Getty Images

Halsey

HalseyKevork Djansezian/Getty Images

Evan Ross and Ashlee Simpson

Evan Ross and Ashlee SimpsonEmma McIntyre/Getty Images

Camila Cabello

Camila CabelloFrazer Harrison /Getty Images

Dua Lipa

Dua LipaEmma McIntyre/Getty Images

Poppy

PoppyEmma McIntyre/Getty Images