Family doctors are “not doing enough” to curb STDs
Julie Lopez has been tested regularly for sexually transmitted infections since she was a teenager. But when the 21-year-old first asked her primary care doctor about screening, he reacted with surprise, she said.
“He said people don’t usually ask. But I did,” Lopez, a college student in Pasadena, California, said. “It’s really important.”
Lopez usually goes to Planned Parenthood instead for the tests because “they ask the questions that need to be asked,” she said.
As rates of sexually transmitted infections steadily rise nationwide, public health officials and experts say primary care doctors need to step up screening and treatment.
“We know that doctors are not doing enough screening for STDs,” David Harvey, executive director at the National Coalition of STD Directors, said. The failure to screen routinely “is leading to an explosion in STD rates,” he said, adding that cutbacks in funding and a lack of patient awareness about the risks make it worse.
The federal government’s Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has set guidelines for annual screening for sexually active individuals. Among them: Sexually active women under 25 should be tested for gonorrhea and chlamydia, and men who have sex with men should get tested for syphilis, chlamydia and gonorrhea.
However, testing does not always happen as recommended. For example, only about half of sexually active women ages 16 to 24 with private health plans or Medicaid were screened for chlamydia in 2015. The rate was slightly better in California.
Nationally, reported cases of chlamydia, gonorrhea and syphilis are at an all-time high, CDC data shows. In one year, from 2016 to 2017, nationwide rates of chlamydia rose by 7%, gonorrhea by 19% and syphilis by 11%.
Rates of congenital syphilis, which passes from mother to baby during pregnancy or delivery, increased by 44% during that time. Nearly one-third of the congenital syphilis cases are from California. The state also saw a record number of STIs last year: more than 300,000 cases of gonorrhea, chlamydia and early syphilis among adults.
Because sexually transmitted infections are often asymptomatic, screening is essential. Untreated STIs can lead to serious health problems, such as chronic pain, infertility or even death.
“Providers and primary care providers play a crucial role in combating these rising STD rates,” Dr. Laura Bachmann, chief medical officer for the CDC division of STD prevention, said. “If providers don’t ask the questions and don’t apply the screening recommendations, the majority of STDs will be missed.”
State governments don’t have enough money to combat the rising number of cases, in part because federal STI funding for them has remained stagnant, Harvey said. In 2017, he said, $152.3 million in federal funding was appropriated for prevention, the same as eight years earlier.
Experts cite several reasons why primary care physicians don’t routinely diagnose and treat STIs. They may worry that they won’t be compensated for providing STI services, or they may not be familiar with the most up-to-date recommendations about testing and treatment. For example, the CDC in 2015 updated the medications it recommends to treat gonorrhea.
Perhaps most commonly, many family physicians are reluctant to discuss sexual health with their patients. One study showed that one-third of adolescents had annual visits that didn’t include any discussion about sexuality.
“We’re in this situation with health care providers and patients — each waiting for the other to start [the conversation],” Dr. Edward Hook, professor at the University of Alabama at Birmingham School of Medicine, said. “Doctors worry if they ask patients about their sexual history that it will somehow be offensive to them.”
Dr. Michael Munger, president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, said he remembers that his conversations around sexual health with patients were uncomfortable when first meeting them. “There are a lot of challenging conversations you can have with patients,” he said. “But this is important. If we don’t do it, who will?”
Rob Nolan, a writer from Los Angeles, said he gets tested every six months, but he prefers to do so at the Los Angeles LGBT Center rather than during visits with his regular doctor, who Nolan said rarely asks about sexual health.
Nolan, who said he has had experience with STIs, considers the LGBT Center clinic’s staff to be more knowledgeable about sexual health than staff at a regular doctor’s office.
“They just seem specialized in it,” he said. “And there is zero shame when you are in the clinic.”
Physicians also may have other, more immediate health issues to address during the short time they have with patients. Taking a sexual history and talking about sexual health falls to the bottom of many doctors’ priorities, Dr. Leo Moore, acting medical director of the division of HIV and STD programs for the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health, said.
Julia Brewer, a nurse practitioner at Northeast Community Clinic in Hawthorne, California, said she screens for STIs as a regular part of women’s health exams. But she said her colleagues frequently refer cases to her rather than having the conversations themselves.
“The family providers are overwhelmed with diabetes and high blood pressure,” she said. Sexual health, she said, can end up being an “afterthought.”
The LA County public health department, which identified STIs as a key priority, recently sent representatives to doctors’ offices to teach providers how to address sexually transmitted infections. They distributed information detailing screening recommendations, sample sexual history questions and treatment guidelines.
The Los Angeles County Medical Association also plans to get the word out to doctors through social media and other efforts. “It’s an epidemic and we have to treat it that way,” CEO Gustavo Friederichsen said. “Doctors have to feel a sense of urgency.”
Dr. Heidi Bauer, who heads the California Department of Public Health’s STD control branch, said the state also is trying to educate doctors so they will screen more routinely. The department provides both in-person and online training for doctors to learn about STIs, and publishes downloadable information with current guidelines.
At the same time, Bauer urged the federal government to make its screening recommendations more comprehensive. Outside of pregnancy, for example, there are no recommendations for routine syphilis screening for women.
“We are seeing this huge re-emergence of syphilis,” she said. “We haven’t been testing, and syphilis is very challenging to diagnose.”
The CDC plans to review the recommendations in the next year, Bachmann said.
Kaiser Health News is a nonprofit news service covering health issues. It is an editorially independent program of the Kaiser Family Foundation that is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.